Felix wins Best of Breed at SBTCA National 2025

Bold, Fearless and Totally Reliable. But What IS Reliable?

We repeat these words often, but I sometimes wonder whether we all interpret them in quite the same way. Bold and fearless are reasonably easy to imagine, although even those qualities can be misunderstood. It’s the last two words, totally reliable, that I find particularly interesting. What exactly is a reliable Stafford, and what should we expect that reliability to look like?

There has long been a difference of opinion among Stafford people about what constitutes correct temperament. Some of the more traditional breeders and enthusiasts believe a Stafford should be spirited, intense, perhaps even a little fired up, and that anything less risks losing the character that made this breed what it is. Others favor a calmer, more laid-back Stafford, one that is easier to manage in today’s society, more comfortable in public settings, and perhaps easier to place in the average family home.

I can understand how both views developed, but I don’t believe either is entirely correct when taken to an extreme. And if our intention is to breed to the standard, rather than to our personal preferences or what happens to be most convenient, I think we need to look a little more carefully at what the standard is actually asking of us.

The Royal Kennel Club describes the Stafford as bold, fearless and totally reliable, while the American Kennel Club standard speaks of indomitable courage, intelligence, tenacity, affection for friends and children, off-duty quietness, and trustworthy stability. Different wording, certainly, but neither standard describes a dog that should be constantly looking for confrontation. Nor do they describe a dog whose greatest virtue is simply being easy to live with.

A Stafford should not have to be fired up to demonstrate courage, nor should it have to be laid-back to demonstrate reliability.

To me, boldness is confidence. It is the willingness to engage with the world, to investigate something unfamiliar, and to approach life with that unmistakable Stafford enthusiasm. Fearlessness is courage, determination, and the ability to face uncertainty without being overwhelmed by it. Neither requires a dog to be constantly excited, challenging, or difficult to manage. Equally, a quiet, easygoing dog may possess enormous courage and determination beneath an otherwise relaxed exterior.

Perhaps that is where we sometimes get into trouble. We begin selecting for the outward behavior we personally admire rather than considering the underlying temperament that produces it.

A Stafford who becomes highly aroused at the sight of another dog is not necessarily demonstrating superior breed character. A Stafford who remains relaxed in the same situation is not necessarily lacking courage. We cannot determine the quality of a dog’s temperament from one reaction, one encounter, or one particular behavior. We need to understand the dog as a whole.

And this brings me back to the word reliable.

Does reliable mean a Stafford who loves every person it meets? One that gets along with every other dog? One that never growls, never objects, never becomes frightened, and never makes a poor decision? I don’t believe so. Those are unrealistic expectations to place on any living animal, and particularly on a breed whose history includes considerable courage, determination, and a willingness to stand its ground.

We should be able to acknowledge that history without romanticizing confrontation. Not every Stafford is going to appreciate another dog rushing into its personal space, challenging it, or behaving rudely. A Stafford may react to that behavior, and the reaction itself does not automatically indicate an unsound temperament. Reactivity and aggression are not synonymous, although they can overlap, and the circumstances surrounding a response matter enormously.

Nor do I believe that every Stafford must enjoy the company of unfamiliar dogs to be considered well adjusted. Dog sociability and sound temperament are not identical qualities. What matters is understanding the individual, recognizing reasonable boundaries, and distinguishing an appropriate response from one that is excessive, unpredictable, or genuinely concerning.

A reliable Stafford does not have to be everyone’s friend. But neither should we excuse every difficult behavior simply because the dog is a Stafford.

That distinction is important, particularly when we are making breeding decisions. If we continually excuse excessive intensity because we believe it demonstrates correct character, what are we actually preserving? On the other hand, if we continually select for the quietest, most compliant individuals because they are easier to live with or place in homes, could we eventually lose some of the courage, determination, and unmistakable spirit that distinguishes our breed?

I think both possibilities deserve consideration.

Of course, society has changed. Staffords today are expected to navigate crowded public places, travel with their families, attend training classes, participate in sports, and live comfortably in environments that may be very different from those in which the breed developed. Responsible breeders have to consider those realities. We should want dogs that can function well in modern life, and we owe their future owners a realistic understanding of the breed.

But I don’t believe that adapting to modern life should mean quietly redefining breed temperament to suit what is easiest to sell, just as preserving history should never become an excuse for producing dogs that are unnecessarily difficult or unsafe to live with.

There is a difference between preserving a breed and preserving our personal interpretation of it.

I also think we sometimes confuse reliability with obedience or convenience. A beautifully trained Stafford may respond instantly to every command and still lack confidence in unfamiliar circumstances. Another may be independent, mischievous, and occasionally rather selective about following our suggestions, yet possess a wonderfully sound and stable temperament. Training matters, but it is not a substitute for character.

As breeders, we should be asking questions that go beyond whether a dog is particularly spirited or especially easygoing. How does it respond to something unexpected? Does it recover quickly from a surprise? Can it settle when nothing is happening? Is it comfortable with normal human interaction? Does it show confidence without unnecessary confrontation? Can it demonstrate determination when challenged without living in a constant state of excitement? And are those qualities reasonably consistent over time?

I believe these observations tell us much more about temperament than whether a Stafford appears fiery or placid.

There is another side to reliability that I think we sometimes overlook, and that is our own responsibility to be reliable to our dogs. We cannot reasonably expect them to demonstrate good judgment while placing them in situations they are not prepared to handle. We cannot expect endless tolerance from a dog whose communication is ignored, and we should not assume that every Stafford must enjoy everything we have decided it should enjoy.

After more than twenty years of breeding and living with Staffords, I have come to appreciate how different their personalities can be. Some are wonderfully outgoing, others a little more reserved. Some are enthusiastic about everything, while others prefer to observe before joining in. Some are remarkably easygoing, while others have a little more fire in their personalities. I don’t believe these individual differences automatically make one dog more correct than another.

What matters is the character beneath those differences, and whether the qualities we are selecting for are consistent with the breed we say we are preserving.

Perhaps the most interesting word in the Royal Kennel Club’s description is totally. A breed standard describes an ideal, something we should continually strive toward, but it does not offer a guarantee that any dog will behave perfectly in every conceivable situation. Reliability cannot mean the absence of emotion, instinct, individual preferences, or boundaries.

For me, a reliable Stafford is one whose fundamental character is sound and stable. A dog whose courage is not dependent upon confrontation, whose confidence does not disappear when circumstances change, and whose temperament is not defined simply by how easy or difficult it happens to be to manage.

I don’t believe our responsibility as preservation breeders is to produce the most fired-up Stafford, or the most laid-back Stafford. It is to preserve the Stafford described in the breed standard, with the courage, character, intelligence, tenacity, affection, and stability that have made this breed so remarkable.

And perhaps that means being willing to question our own preferences occasionally, whether they were shaped by tradition, personal experience, modern expectations, or simply the dogs we happen to enjoy living with most.

Because when we begin breeding for what we personally prefer, rather than what the standard describes, we may gradually change the very breed we intended to preserve.

Leave a response

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *